Dalmore 12 vs. Cigar Malt Reserve: Which Scotch Should You Buy?

Scotch Debate

The Dalmore 12 and The Dalmore Cigar Malt Reserve share the distillery’s Highland style, but they are built for different buyers. The 12 is an age-stated introduction to the range, while Cigar Malt Reserve uses a more complex multi-cask recipe and a higher bottling strength.

The Dalmore 12

The Dalmore 12 Year Scotch Whisky is a 12-year-old single malt bottled at 40% ABV in its standard global presentation. The distillery says it begins in American white-oak ex-bourbon casks, with a portion finished in aged Oloroso-sherry casks. Official notes emphasize citrus, chocolate, spice, dried fruit, vanilla, coffee and dark chocolate.

The Dalmore Cigar Malt Reserve

The Dalmore Cigar Malt Reserve is bottled at 44% ABV and is matured using ex-bourbon barrels, Cabernet Sauvignon barriques and Matusalem Oloroso-sherry casks. The producer describes cinnamon, vanilla, red fruit, tropical fruit, toffee, orange zest, dark chocolate and spice.

Key differences

Feature Dalmore 12 Cigar Malt Reserve
Age statement 12 years No age statement shown on the official product page
ABV 40% 44%
Cask emphasis Bourbon and Oloroso sherry Bourbon, Cabernet Sauvignon and Matusalem Oloroso
Best fit Introduction, gifts, approachable sipping Richer profile, after-dinner sipping, bolder gift

Which should you choose?

Choose The Dalmore 12 for a recognizable age statement, a gentler proof and a more accessible entry to the house style. Choose Cigar Malt Reserve when the recipient prefers richer fruit, spice and a more layered cask story. Despite the name, it can be enjoyed without a cigar.

Explore more bottles in the Scotch collection. Availability and specifications can vary by market, so check the current bottle and product page.

Official sources

Previous Next