Old Forester The President's Choice Rye Whiskey

The Old Forester The President’s Choice Rye Whiskey represents the pinnacle of barrel-selection and craftsmanship from one of America’s oldest bourbon houses. Hand-picked by the brand’s president, each single barrel is chosen for its exceptional character and bottled at high proof—capturing the bold, nuanced spirit of rye whiskey at its finest. This limited release honors a long legacy while delivering an extraordinary sipping experience for rye lovers and collectors alike.

Why Buy Old Forester The President’s Choice Rye?
Because this isn’t just another rye—it’s a rare, single-barrel expression, drawn from barrels aged 7-9 years and bottled between 110–125 proof, ensuring premium depth, complexity, and intensity. It offers both collector appeal and drinker satisfaction, showcasing what happens when only the finest barrels earn the “President’s Choice” designation. shop.oldforester.com+2PR Newswire+2

The Background
Dating back to 1964, the President’s Choice series was born when Old Forester’s president personally selected single barrels as gifts—a tradition revived recently to honor the brand’s heritage. Now for the first time, the rye variant joins the lineup, with nationwide release and extremely limited distribution. Each barrel is meticulously chosen by the Master Taster and Assistant Master Distiller to deliver the highest quality. Whisky Advocate+1

Tasting Notes & Profile

• Nose: Vanilla-cherry cola, salted caramel, minerality shop.oldforester.com+1

• Palate: Over-ripe banana, warm cedar, brown butter, bay leaf/eucalyptus shop.oldforester.com+1

• Finish: Balanced and dry with moderate pepper spice that lingers shop.oldforester.com+1

The Story
This rye weaves together heritage and modern ambition—Old Forester’s first dedicated President’s Choice Rye marks a milestone in the brand’s evolution. Numbered barrels, single-barrel authenticity, and high-proof presentation turn each bottle into a statement piece that celebrates both tradition and innovation.

Serving Suggestions

• Neat or with a drop of water to open its layered complexity

• Low-water Old Fashioned for a clean, bold rye cocktail

• Premium pairing with dark chocolate, cigars, or a well-curated cigar lounge moment

Our Guarantee
At Quality Liquor Store, every bottle of Old Forester The President’s Choice Rye Whiskey is sourced directly and handled with care. With nationwide release but still ultra-limited supply, this expression is built for discerning drinkers and serious collectors. Secure your bottle today and experience one of the finest rye releases from Old Forester’s most exclusive program.

We know you’ll want to enjoy your Quality Liquor Store purchase as soon as possible. That’s why we’re committed to fast, secure, and compliant delivery.

• Orders ship from our licensed U.S. fulfillment partners
  
• Shipping costs are calculated at checkout
  
• Expedited shipping options may be available
  
• Estimated delivery dates are shown at checkout
  
• Certain items or delivery destinations may incur additional shipping charges
  
• Adult signature (21+) is required upon delivery where applicable
  

If you have any questions about shipping or delivery, our support team is always happy to help.

Your satisfaction is important to us. If you’re not completely satisfied with your purchase, we offer easy returns on eligible items.

• Returns accepted within 14 days of delivery on eligible items
  
• Some products may be final sale due to alcohol regulations
  
• Items marked as final sale are not eligible for return
  
• To request a return, please contact our support team at
  
  info@qualityliquorstore.com
  

For full details, please review our Returns Policy page.

Bottles are securely packaged to prevent damage in transit.

We recommend storing spirits upright, away from direct sunlight and heat.